Two seasons back I got tired of making two trips to the water. My old system was a hard box for crankbaits and a soft bag for plastics and terminal tackle, and every morning at the Wilson Lake ramp I would lug both down the dock, set them on the deck, and then spend the first twenty minutes of good light moving things from one to the other while the shad were already busting up the bank. So I bought the KastKing KarryAll, the medium 20 liter version, and I have fished out of it almost every weekend since. This is the part of the review where I tell you what the listing photos leave out.

Short version first. It is a good bag that solved my two-trip problem, and it is not the bag some of the five star write-ups make it out to be. It holds five 3600 size trays in the main compartment and a sixth up in the top zipper, it has shrugged off spray and one honest rain shower, and the zippers have not popped, split, or lost a pull in two years of Saturdays. It is also not waterproof, the shoulder strap is the only real way to carry it any distance, and 20 liters fills up faster than you expect once the pliers, the scale, and a bottle of water go in. All of that is fine. You just need to know it before you spend the money.

The Quick Verdict

★★★★☆ 8.6/10

A well built 20 liter day bag that carries six 3600 trays and takes a beating, as long as you accept that it is a shoulder bag and not a backpack, and water resistant and not waterproof.

Check Today's Price →

Six Trays, One Shoulder, Zero Trips Back to the Truck

The KarryAll is the bag I reach for on a normal Saturday. 20 liters, five 3600 trays in the main compartment and a sixth up top, 600D oxford that has survived two years of aluminum decks and gravel ramps.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →

What Nobody Tells You About a 20 Liter Bag

Twenty liters sounds enormous until you fill one. A 3600 tray is about the size of a hardback book, and five of them stacked in the main compartment eat nearly all of the floor space. That leaves the top zipper compartment, the utility pocket, and whatever you can wedge down the sides. On a normal trip mine carries five trays, a small box of hooks, a pouch of tungsten weights, a pair of cutters, a scale, sunscreen, and a bottle of water. It all fits. Nothing else fits, and I mean nothing.

The other thing nobody mentions is that a soft bag does not stand up on its own. Set the KastKing bag on the deck empty and it slumps over. Set it there full and it holds its shape, because the trays are doing the structural work. That is not a defect, that is how a soft shell behaves, but if you are used to a hard box you can drop on the front deck and forget about, this is a different animal and it takes a couple of trips to stop reaching for it like one.

Last thing on size. Medium, 13 inches long, 11 wide, 11 tall. On a 17 foot aluminum boat with a bow mount trolling motor and a couple of rod lockers, that footprint sits behind my seat without crowding my feet or the net. On a kayak it would be most of the tankwell. Measure the space you actually have before you assume 20 liters is a small bag, because it is not small. It is a day bag, and a day bag is exactly what most of us need.

An angler's hands opening the main zipper of a tackle bag on an aluminum boat deck, flat lure trays visible inside

How I Have Used It

My routine has not changed much in forty years. I am on the water before the ramp lights quit, I fish the Tennessee River lakes out of a 17 foot aluminum boat with a 40 horse outboard, and I am usually home before Darlene starts asking where I got to. The KarryAll rides behind the driver's seat with the strap looped over the seat post, and it does not slide around when I get on the trolling motor and start working a bank. That sounds like a small thing. It is not, because a bag that slides means you are stopping every ten minutes to kick it back out of the way.

I have carried it a fair piece on foot too. Some of the farm ponds I fish, you park at the gate and walk a quarter mile of turn row to get to the water. That is where the bag shows its one real weakness and I will get to it in a minute. On the boat it is close to perfect. Empty, the bag itself is 0.85 kg, a little under two pounds, which matches what my kitchen scale said the day I unboxed it. Loaded, mine is heavier than that, but I have never put it on a scale full and I am not going to guess at a number.

Ruby comes with me on calm mornings. She is a six year old black Lab mix, about sixty pounds, and she has learned to lie between the seats and stay clear of anything with a treble hook on it. The bag has taken more abuse from her than from the lake. She has stepped on it, leaned against it, and once knocked it off the bench seat onto the bare aluminum, and the 600D oxford did not tear, scuff through, or leave a mark I could find. That afternoon sold me on the shell more than any listing bullet could.

Two years of Saturdays, five 3600 trays in the main compartment and one up top, and the zippers have not popped once. That is the whole review in one sentence.

The Box Math: Five Trays in the Main, One Up Top

The listing says six 3600 size boxes and that number is honest, but the six is split. Five go in the main compartment, laid flat or stood on edge, and the sixth goes in the upper zipper section. If you are the angler who wants eight trays of crankbaits sorted by depth and color, this is not that bag and no amount of rearranging will make it one. If you want a working selection for a day on the water, five plus one is plenty, and it is more organized than the loose pile of boxes most of us started with.

One thing to check before you order. The bag is 13 inches long and a 3700 tray is 14 inches, so 3700s do not lie flat in the main compartment. I tried it. They bind at the corners and the lid will not close clean, and forcing it just puts a bend in the tray. The 3600 size is what this bag was built around, so plan on 3600s and buy them before the bag shows up.

The trays are not included, and while the listing says so, people miss it. I already owned mine, so the swap cost me nothing but an evening of sorting plastics into the new boxes. If you are coming over from bank fishing with a single small box and a backpack, add the trays to your total before you decide, because an empty KarryAll is just a nice bag with nothing to organize.

Water Resistant Is Not the Same as Waterproof

The shell is 600D oxford and the listing calls it water resistant. That word is doing exactly the work it should, no more. Spray off a wet deck beads up and rolls off. A misty morning does nothing. I got caught in a straight line shower on Pickwick in April, the kind that comes on with no warning and quits in fifteen minutes, and I shoved the bag under the console and stayed on the trolling motor. When it passed, the outside was soaked and the inside was dry except for a little damp along the top zipper.

A little damp along a zipper is what water resistant means. If you leave this bag on an open deck through an all day rain, or set it down in the bilge water that collects under the seat, the contents will get wet. I have not lost a lure to rust because of it, but I also do not leave it out. The bag goes under the console or in the truck at the end of the day. That habit is worth more than any coating on any bag I have owned.

The zippers deserve their own note, because zippers are where cheap bags die. Three zippered compartments, all of them still working, no split teeth, no pull that came off in my hand, no slider that needs a wiggle to catch. I do not baby them. I load the main compartment until it is tight and I pull the lid shut with one hand while holding a rod in the other. Two years in, that is the part of the bag I trust most.

A tackle bag set on weathered dock boards beside a steel thermos and a pair of fishing pliers, low sun on the water

The Strap, the Handle, and the Walk Back to the Truck

Here is the honest part. The KarryAll has a shoulder strap and a web handle, no wheels, and it is not a backpack. On the boat, none of that matters. On a quarter mile walk down a turn row to a farm pond, the shoulder strap starts working on you about halfway. The bag is not heavy, but it hangs off one shoulder and swings with your stride, and by the time I reach the water I am ready to set it down and stretch. That is the trade you make for a bag this size with a single strap.

The web handle is fine for lifting it in and out of the truck bed. It is not a carry-it-across-a-field handle. If walking distance is a big part of your fishing, and for a lot of bank anglers it is, a bag with two straps or a set of wheels is worth a hard look. I still carry this one, because my walk is short and the boat is where it lives. But I am not going to pretend it is a hiking pack, and neither should you.

One more small thing that turned out to matter. Loaded, the shape is set by the trays, so the bag sits flat and stable on a boat deck or a tailgate. Set it on a slope and it leans but does not tip, because the weight sits low. I have had it on the front deck in a chop and it stayed put, which is more than I could say for the loose boxes it replaced. Small victories are still victories.

What Has Held Up and What Has Not

Held up: the oxford shell, the zippers, the stitching at the strap anchors, and the overall shape. Two years of gravel ramps, wet decks, a dog stepping on it, and one afternoon where it slid off the bench seat onto aluminum, and there is no tear, no frayed seam, and no spot where the material has gone thin. That is the whole reason I am writing this instead of throwing it in the trash and buying something else.

Not held up, or at least not perfectly: my patience with a single shoulder strap on a long walk, and the top zipper compartment during a real rain. Neither is a failure. They are the trade-offs of a soft 20 liter bag, and they are the two things I would want a friend to tell me before he ordered one. A hard box would keep the rain out and bark my shins every trip. A wheeled bag would walk itself to the pond and then take up half the deck. This one sits in the middle, and the middle is where most of my fishing lives.

What I Liked

  • Holds five 3600 trays in the main compartment plus a sixth up top, which covers a full day of bass fishing
  • 600D oxford shell has taken two years of gravel ramps, wet decks and a dog without a tear or a frayed seam
  • Three zippered compartments stay where you put them, with no split teeth and no lost pulls
  • Water resistant coating sheds spray and a short shower, keeping the trays dry
  • At 0.85 kg empty and 13 by 11 by 11 inches, it sits behind the seat on a 17 foot boat without crowding anything

Where It Falls Short

  • Not waterproof. The top zipper lets damp through in a real rain, so the bag needs to go under cover
  • One shoulder strap and a web handle, no wheels, so long walks to a pond get old fast
  • 3700 trays do not fit flat. This is a 3600 bag and nothing changes that
  • Trays are not included, so plan for five or six boxes on top of the bag
  • 20 liters fills faster than the number suggests once tools and a water bottle go in

Who This Is For

This bag is for the angler who fishes from a small boat, a kayak, or the bank and wants one bag carrying a working selection of baits, a few tools, and nothing else. If you keep four or five 3600 trays of plastics, crankbaits, and jigs, plus terminal tackle up top, this is sized right for you. It is also for the person who is tired of two bags and wants to grab one thing out of the truck in the dark. The KastKing KarryAll does that job without drama, and two years in it still does it.

Who Should Skip It

Skip it if you carry eight or ten trays, because 20 liters will not do it and you will end up back at two bags inside a month. Skip it if your fishing involves a long walk, because a single shoulder strap on a loaded bag is a chore by the second quarter mile. Skip it if you fish in the rain with no console or truck nearby, since water resistant is not waterproof. And skip it if you are not going to buy 3600 trays, because an empty KarryAll is just a well made bag with nothing to organize.

The Bag I Grab When I Only Want to Make One Trip

20 liters, six 3600 trays, 600D oxford, and two years of Wilson Lake Saturdays behind it. If that matches how you fish, it is worth a look before your next early start.

See the KarryAll on Amazon →