The thing that finally pushed me out of a hard tackle box was a wet Saturday on Wilson Lake, not a catalog. I had dumped half a box of crankbaits across the front deck of the jon boat, and the lid I was sure was latched was not.

I ran that same box for years. It held plenty. It also rattled every time I hit a wake, and the trays had a way of sliding out of order so the one I wanted was always on the bottom. When it started raining, the box held water in just as well as it held baits. I spent twenty minutes on my knees picking treble hooks out of carpet while the fish were blowing up twenty yards away. That afternoon I decided I was done fighting my own storage.

A hand lifting a 3600 size tackle tray out of the open main compartment of a soft-sided tackle bag resting on a boat deck

I picked up the KastKing KarryAll that spring and have run it through a full season of Tuesday evenings and Saturday mornings since. It is a soft-sided bag, 20 liters, and it weighs right at 0.85 kg empty. That last number matters more than it sounds. I carry it from the truck to the ramp in one hand along with a rod, and I do not have to make two trips for the box and the extras.

What sold me was how it swallows trays. The main compartment takes five 3600 size boxes vertically or horizontally, and with the upper section you can get six in the bag with terminal tackle and tools in the mix. I run five trays in the main body and keep that sixth spot for a small box of hooks and weights. There are three zippered compartments, plus a utility pocket that has become the home for my line clippers, pliers and a spare spool of fluorocarbon. Nothing in there is fancy. It is just the right shape for the way I already sort baits.

The shell is 600D oxford, and KastKing lists it as water resistant. I can confirm the water resistant part. It has ridden through two pop up storms on Pickwick and the trays inside stayed dry. It is not a dry bag and I would not set it down in standing water, but the rain that used to pool in my old box now beads and runs off this one.

Five 3600 trays, pliers, line clippers and a rain jacket in one bag I can pick up with two fingers. That is the whole reason it stays in the boat.

Load It Once and Stop Thinking About It

The bag is the one piece of gear that should never cost you fishing time. Check the current specs, size and today's price on Amazon, then load it the night before and leave it loaded.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →

The carry side of it is simple, and I mean that as a compliment. There is a shoulder strap for the long walk from the parking lot and a web handle on top for grabbing it out of the boat. The KastKing KarryAll measures 13 by 11 by 11 inches, so it slides under the console of my 17 foot aluminum boat and sits between the seats without me tripping over it. I have not once had to move it to get to the trolling motor, which was a weekly argument with the old box.

A soft-sided tackle bag sitting on weathered dock planks beside a landing net and a thermos, lake blurred in the background

Nothing is perfect, so here is what I do not like. The soft shell means it will not protect anything from being stepped on, and a soft bag on a boat deck will get stepped on. The zippers pick up sand and grit. I rinse and dry them every few trips, and I keep the bag up off the deck when I can. If you want something you can drop off a tailgate and forget about, a hard box still wins that argument, and I would not pretend otherwise.

There is also a sorting habit that matters more than the bag itself. It holds a lot, and if you stuff it you will spend ten minutes digging for a chatterbait you can hear but cannot see. I keep the main trays in the same order every trip and the terminal tackle in its own tray. The bag rewards that habit and punishes laziness, which seems fair.

Ruby rides with me on calm mornings and I have to watch her around treble hooks. The bag helped there too, and that surprised me. Hooks and baits stay zipped in a tray instead of lying loose on the deck where a 60 pound Lab mix can find them. That alone covered the change for me. Darlene has stopped asking why the garage smells like bait, mostly because the bag closes all the way and the trays stay inside it.

If you are weighing it against a Plano Guide Series, the short version is that the hard box wins on protection and the KarryAll wins on how much it carries and how easy it is to move. I fish from a small boat and from the bank on farm ponds, so the soft bag fits my day better. If I were standing on a rocky tailrace all afternoon I might feel different.

What I'd Tell You If We Were Sitting at My Kitchen Table

Buy the bag for the way you actually fish, not the way the tackle aisle says you should. Most of us carry more than we throw. The KastKing KarryAll holds six 3600 boxes if you load it full, and you probably do not need six. Load five, keep the terminal tray, and leave the rest on the bench at home. The bag will still be the right size next season, and your shoulder will thank you on the walk back up the ramp. If you want more of my notes before you spend anything, read the long term review and the comparison against the Plano before you decide. Either way, get the gear out of a wet box and back into something you can carry.

One Bag, Loaded the Night Before, Ready Before Daylight

If you are still hauling a rattling hard box plus a loose bag of plastics, this is the swap that ends it. Compare the KarryAll listing against your own tray count and see whether it fits your boat.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →